How Were Bourdieu's Theories Similar to and Different from Karl Marx?

<<< back to blog
It has often been posited that Pierre Bourdieu was a Marxist or 'Marxist writer' and that he drew many of his ideas and theories from Karl Marx. It is true that they do have similarities but there are also significant differences in the way in which they understood the world. These are the main ways in which the two theorists shared ideas but also differed.

Similarities:
Class: Both Bourdieu and Marx focus on class and its influence on society. Marx believed that class conflict was the driving force of historical change, while Bourdieu believed that class influences an individual's cultural tastes and behaviors.

Social Structure: Both scholars believed that social structure, particularly economic and cultural structures, shapes individuals' lives and behaviors.

Power: Both scholars recognized the importance of power and its role in society. Marx believed that power is held by the ruling class and used to maintain their control over the working class. Similarly, Bourdieu believed that power is held by those who possess cultural capital, which enables them to dominate others.

Critical Theory: Both Bourdieu and Marx were critical theorists who sought to uncover and challenge the underlying power structures and inequalities that exist in society.
Differences:

Methodology: Bourdieu's methodological approach was more empirical and relied on qualitative research methods, while Marx's was more theoretical and relied on historical analysis and quantitative methods.

Conceptualisation of Capital: Marx saw capital as economic and monetary, while Bourdieu expanded and extended the idea of capital to include not only the economic realm, but also cultural and social forms of capital such as education, social networks, and cultural tastes.

Focus: Following on from their differing perceptions of capital, Marx focused primarily on the economic structures of society and the struggle between the ruling class and the working class. Bourdieu focused on the role of culture in maintaining social hierarchies and the influence of cultural capital on individuals' lives.
Agency: Marx believed that individuals have agency and the ability to take action to challenge the dominant power structures. Bourdieu, on the other hand, emphasized the role of habitus, which limits individuals' agency and influences their behaviors and decisions.

Overall then, while both Marx and Bourdieu have made significant contributions to our understanding of society, with a focus on social class and inequality they differ in their emphasis on the role of economic factors, the importance of cultural practices, and their view on social change.
Created with